Home Page
   Articles
       links
About Us    
Traders        
Recipes            
Latest Articles
Solar panels for garden classroom

 
Post new topic   Reply to topic    Downsizer Forum Index -> Energy Efficiency and Construction/Major Projects
Author 
 Message
charitygardener



Joined: 17 Sep 2013
Posts: 4

PostPosted: Tue Sep 17, 13 9:38 am    Post subject: Solar panels for garden classroom Reply with quote
    

Hi, Just joined this forum as I need advice! I run a small gardening charity working with adults with learning difficulties and we are about to dismantle our knackered portacabin and replace it with a wooden 16'x14' 'leisure cabin' which we will use as a classroom. We have no access to electricity so are wondering about installing some kind of solar panel for lighting. As we are based in a public garden we have security issues so I need advice about the type of solar panels which caravanners use. We will need to run a couple of light bulbs off of the panel at least and would really appreciate some help from people who know about such things! Are these fold up panels any good? Would it provide enough power to give us sufficient light in winter? How big a battery is needed? Am I completely going in the wrong direction?? As we will be applying for funding for this I really need to make sure of the facts as we can't afford to get it wrong. Thanks in anticipation!

vegplot



Joined: 19 Apr 2007
Posts: 21301
Location: Bethesda, Gwynedd
PostPosted: Tue Sep 17, 13 10:05 am    Post subject: Reply with quote
    

Welcome to the forum.

There are a number of people here who have some experience of this and they will probably be along soon. There are also specialist forums you can ask such as https://www.navitron.org.uk/forum/. Also, have you consider alternatives such as this? https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-pacific-14967535

RichardW



Joined: 24 Aug 2006
Posts: 8443
Location: Llyn Peninsular North Wales
PostPosted: Tue Sep 17, 13 10:53 am    Post subject: Reply with quote
    

The devil is in the detail.

Which lights & how many?
how many watts each?
how many hours per day?
how many days per week?
how many weeks per year?
how critical is it if it fails to work on the 20th bad solar day in a row in deep winter?


To be honest (having helped spec things like this many times before) what you want to achieve is going to cost lots more than you think. If there really is no way you can get mains elec then having a removable battery that you charge at home will be about 10% of the cost of going off grid. Add in the security issues & I feel that 100% solar is not the way to go.

A system that could supply 100% of your needs in summer will only supply less than 10% in winter.

charitygardener



Joined: 17 Sep 2013
Posts: 4

PostPosted: Fri Sep 20, 13 4:15 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote
    

Well, I really can't have mains power so some kind of green power source is our only option I think. We only use the classroom for maybe three hours, four days a week and in the direst weather we work indoors in my office anyway. The irony is that we are based at an alternative/green energy centre powered by a massive wind turbine which supplies the local town too. I've asked about being able to connect to the power supply but have been told it's not possible several times. Anyone with an electric car can power up for free but we can't access the source. There is even an incredibly sophisticated tracking solar panel array within fifty feet of our intended site. I have no idea why they are so unhelpful but it's how it is....
It sounds to me as if we are going to have to do without lighting still which is a shame as it really impacts on our work. Thanks for your assistance anyway.

Jam Lady



Joined: 28 Dec 2006
Posts: 2506
Location: New Jersey, USA
PostPosted: Fri Sep 20, 13 9:54 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote
    

We sometimes go off-grid when a storm knocks out the mains electricity for anywhere from an hour to 14 days (the record, and one I'm not eager to repeat.)

When the outage occurs we use a generator. Different models run on propane, diesel, or on gasoline - that's petrol for you.

Now keep in mind that we're trying to keep the freezer frozen, refrigerator cold, and well pump supplying necessary water in addition to lights etc. You just want to run a few lights on gloomy days

A small portable generator might be just the ticket - small enough to transport in a car, useful for what you want.

I Googled using "camping generator sizes" for the search term and one web site had this: "Lightweight, compact generators provide up to 1000 watts of power. They are ideal for powering TV’s, electric razors, gaming consoles, and small lights and fans."

It also said that the noise would be comparable to a normal conversation. So perhaps this might work for you.

charitygardener



Joined: 17 Sep 2013
Posts: 4

PostPosted: Mon Sep 23, 13 10:35 am    Post subject: Reply with quote
    

Ooh, now that is a thought! I was trying really hard to keep within the ethos of the centre we're based at that I may have developed tunnel vision! Thanks very much, Jam Lady - I shall have a google post haste.

Tarrel



Joined: 17 Nov 2012
Posts: 18
Location: Ross-shire, Scotland
PostPosted: Mon Sep 23, 13 7:34 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote
    

You really shouldn't have any problems in putting in a solar-powered system for what you need.

The basic setup you need is:
- A solar panel (Your input)
- a charge controller (controls when your panel is charging the battery)
- a leisure battery (your energy store)
- an inverter (to boost the power up to mains voltage)
- some low energy lights

Over a period of,say, a week, the amount of energy produced by your solar panel should equal the amount used by your lights. The storage in the battery will even out the peaks and troughs (say you have a cloudy day in which you use the lights a lot but produce little solar energy, followed by a sunny day when you don't need the lights but produce loads of electricity!)

so, in more detail:

Lights:
In our large kitchen diner we use 5W LED lights to replace the 50W halogens that were there before. The LEDs easily produce as much light as the halogens. For your cabin, I guess you might need four light fittings, each with two directional halogen-style lights. If you use 5W LEDs that's a total load of 40W (8 x 5W). If you ran them for, say, five hours, you would use 200 Watt-hours of electricity.

Inverter:
A cheap 150W inverter will cost you about £20 and will be quite sufficient to run your 40W worth of lights. Halfords, etc, supply them to plug in to your car cigarette lighter.

Battery:
You need a Leisure Battery. You can get these from Caravan stockists, or places like "Go Outdoors". A leisure battery is designed for deep discharge, i.e. regular charging and discharging. A normal car battery on the other hand is deisgned to be constantly topped up. It will be damaged by regular deep discharging. A 75Ah leisure battery should cost around £75. (Ah = "Amp-hour", a measure of the battery's capacity. It means it can deliver 75 Amps for one hour, or 7.5 Amps for 10 hours, etc. it will do this at 12 Volts. Volts x Amps = Watts, so a 75Ah battery will deliver around 900 watt-hours. In other words, it would run your 40W lighting set-up for around 22 hours without recharging).

Solar Panel:
Panels are measured in Wp (Watts peak). So, an 80Wp panel will deliver 80 Watts in full sun. On a cloudy day, or if the sun is low in the sky, it could deliver a lot less. So, in full sun for, say, six hours, your panel would deliver 480 Watt-hours, enough to half charge your battery, and more than twice what your lights will have used when kept on for 5 hours. So, on a sunny day, you'll be putting more energy into your battery than you are using with your lights.

An 80W panel is around 100cm x 60cm in size, and is easily moved around by hand. You could keep it in the cabin and bring it out when you open up. You could make up a wooden stand for it, ideally angled at about 45 degrees to the sun. Alternatively, it would look fairly unobtrusive on the roof, and would be collecting energy whenever the sun is up (e.g 5 am on a summer morning!). By the way, the folding "solar briefcase" things are good, and they come with a charge controller, but they are only 13 Watts.

Expect to pay around £1 per Watt for a solar panel.

That basically leaves the charge-contoller. This manages the relationship between your panel and the battery. If you were confident that your panel would never deliver more energy than your battery can hold, you wouldn't really need one, but it's better to have one. They come in different ratings, according to the size of the panel you are using. Ebay or Navitron are useful sources, but Google "solar charge controllers" and you should get some decent sources.

IMHO a generator will be overkill for what you need, it takes fuel, creates pollution and noise.

Another possible solution taht occurs is to just have the leisure battery running the LED lights and take it home every 2-3 days and charge it off a battery charger!

Hope this makes sense. Any questions, do ask.

RichardW



Joined: 24 Aug 2006
Posts: 8443
Location: Llyn Peninsular North Wales
PostPosted: Mon Sep 23, 13 8:55 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote
    

Tarrel wrote:
You really shouldn't have any problems in putting in a solar-powered system for what you need.

Agreed

The basic setup you need is:
- A solar panel (Your input)
- a charge controller (controls when your panel is charging the battery)
- a leisure battery (your energy store)
- an inverter (to boost the power up to mains voltage) optional if you use low voltage lights & you will save on the energy used
- some low energy lights

Over a period of,say, a week, the amount of energy produced by your solar panel should equal the amount used by your lights.

Wrong it will need to exceed it by the charge cycle efficiency (about 1.2 times) & any inverter efficiency (80-90%) if one is used.

The storage in the battery will even out the peaks and troughs (say you have a cloudy day in which you use the lights a lot but produce little solar energy, followed by a sunny day when you don't need the lights but produce loads of electricity!)

so, in more detail:

Lights:
In our large kitchen diner we use 5W LED lights to replace the 50W halogens that were there before. The LEDs easily produce as much light as the halogens. For your cabin, I guess you might need four light fittings, each with two directional halogen-style lights. If you use 5W LEDs that's a total load of 40W (8 x 5W). If you ran them for, say, five hours, you would use 200 Watt-hours of electricity.

Inverter:
A cheap 150W inverter will cost you about £20 and will be quite sufficient to run your 40W worth of lights. Halfords, etc, supply them to plug in to your car cigarette lighter.

Battery:
You need a Leisure Battery. You can get these from Caravan stockists, or places like "Go Outdoors". A leisure battery is designed for deep discharge, i.e. regular charging and discharging. A normal car battery on the other hand is deisgned to be constantly topped up. It will be damaged by regular deep discharging. A 75Ah leisure battery should cost around £75. (Ah = "Amp-hour", a measure of the battery's capacity. It means it can deliver 75 Amps for one hour, or 7.5 Amps for 10 hours, etc. it will do this at 12 Volts. Volts x Amps = Watts, so a 75Ah battery will deliver around 900 watt-hours. In other words, it would run your 40W lighting set-up for around 22 hours without recharging).

No it wont, well ok it will but not for many times. You can kill a battery by one full discharge cycle. Far better to stick to 50% discharge or less

Solar Panel:
Panels are measured in Wp (Watts peak). So, an 80Wp panel will deliver 80 Watts in full sun. On a cloudy day, or if the sun is low in the sky, it could deliver a lot less. So, in full sun for, say, six hours, your panel would deliver 480 Watt-hours, enough to half charge your battery, and more than twice what your lights will have used when kept on for 5 hours. So, on a sunny day, you'll be putting more energy into your battery than you are using with your lights.

True but most likely you wont need 5 hours of lights if you had 6 hours worth or full sun. Try doing the same calc for when its not summer. Think in terms of 1 x panels worth of energy all day IE 80Wh when you need 5 hours of lights. Times that up by a weeks usage & see how the system copes.

An 80W panel is around 100cm x 60cm in size, and is easily moved around by hand. You could keep it in the cabin and bring it out when you open up. You could make up a wooden stand for it, ideally angled at about 45 degrees to the sun.

Try 90 degrees to the sun.

Alternatively, it would look fairly unobtrusive on the roof, and would be collecting energy whenever the sun is up (e.g 5 am on a summer morning!). By the way, the folding "solar briefcase" things are good, and they come with a charge controller, but they are only 13 Watts.

Expect to pay around £1 per Watt for a solar panel.

Your a bit out of date. Try nearer 50p per watt. Just dont go for "off grid" type panels. You can just about get a full on grid install for £1 per watt now days

That basically leaves the charge-contoller. This manages the relationship between your panel and the battery. If you were confident that your panel would never deliver more energy than your battery can hold,

(Rubbish, its not what it holds but how much you have used that would matter)

you wouldn't really need one, but it's better to have one. They come in different ratings, according to the size of the panel you are using. Ebay or Navitron are useful sources, but Google "solar charge controllers" and you should get some decent sources.

IMHO a generator will be overkill for what you need, it takes fuel, creates pollution and noise.

Another possible solution taht occurs is to just have the leisure battery running the LED lights and take it home every 2-3 days and charge it off a battery charger!

Hope this makes sense. Any questions, do ask.

Tarrel



Joined: 17 Nov 2012
Posts: 18
Location: Ross-shire, Scotland
PostPosted: Mon Sep 23, 13 11:01 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote
    

Could you give me some pointers as to where I can get 40-80 W panels for 50p per Watt? Seriously; I'm in the market. I know you can get 250W ones for that price, but I doubt that's what the OP would need in their situation.

Sorry about the 45 degrees; I meant 45 degrees to the horizon!


In my experience, mains voltage LEDs have progressed far more than 12v ones in terms of efficiency and quality of light in the last few months. Again, if you have a source of 12v LEDs that can match the best of the 240V ones, I'd be interested, as I have an offgrid setup in our woodland cabin and haven't found anything yet to match the quality of light provided by 240V GU10s.

My aim was to present to the OP a sense of how such a system would work. Hopefully with your clarification they now have all the info they need, but haven't been put off by excessive complexity.

RichardW



Joined: 24 Aug 2006
Posts: 8443
Location: Llyn Peninsular North Wales
PostPosted: Tue Sep 24, 13 7:08 am    Post subject: Reply with quote
    

Google is your friend lol.

I know that Bimble solar have some 125 watt panels at 44p.

As we use mains LED I have never done a comparison between 12v & mains versions. I do know that lots of people do use low V ones successfully. LED light quality is a very subjective with everyone preferring a different temperature, brightness or colour.

Quote:
Hopefully with your clarification they now have all the info they need, but haven't been put off by excessive complexity.


Trouble is if you want a system that "just works as needed" then you need to either spend more money than you need to or get complicated ensuring it will cope.

charitygardener



Joined: 17 Sep 2013
Posts: 4

PostPosted: Tue Sep 24, 13 11:28 am    Post subject: Reply with quote
    

All this information is so helpful - thank you all so much. I can go to my trustees and not sound like a total idiot when I'm convincing them that this is a good idea!

I'll have to price it all up and put in a funding bid so I'll let you know how we got on. Thanks once again!

mark



Joined: 14 Jul 2005
Posts: 2191
Location: Leeds
PostPosted: Tue Sep 24, 13 4:32 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote
    

In locations like this solar panels and generators tend to get stolen. That can rocket costs up very quickly as you shed /building gets damaged too!

Moving batteries to and from can be pretty heavy if you are not near the road though.

Do you only need lighting or do you also need heating. I'd have though a winter class needed to keep warm. So maybe you should be thinking propane or paraffin for heating and lighting? Just like an old fashioned camp site! Just a thought!

If you do go for battery or solar powered lights though go for the most efficient LED lighting - you 've more chance of staying viable in winter or early spring/ late autumn.

Mark

dpack



Joined: 02 Jul 2005
Posts: 45460
Location: yes
PostPosted: Thu Sep 26, 13 11:36 am    Post subject: Reply with quote
    

a lithium battery and mains charger,portable

led lights ,fitted

Post new topic   Reply to topic    Downsizer Forum Index -> Energy Efficiency and Construction/Major Projects All times are GMT
Page 1 of 1
View Latest Posts View Latest Posts

 

Archive
Powered by php-BB © 2001, 2005 php-BB Group
Style by marsjupiter.com, released under GNU (GNU/GPL) license.
Copyright © 2004 marsjupiter.com