Archive for Downsizer For an ethical approach to consumption
 


       Downsizer Forum Index -> Site guidelines, Announcements, Problems and Suggestions
marigold

Logging in to DS

If I sign in on the home page I have to sign in again to access the forum and if I sign out from the forum the home page thinks I'm still signed in. It's a bit confusing and seems unnecessary. If it's an unavoidable feature explanatory messages might be helpful Smile .
jema

There are seperate login systems, it "may" be possible to unify them, but I struggled and failed to do so back in the mists of time.
marigold

Is there actually any need to have a login for the main site? I only went to the home page because I'd directed someone to DS and I logged in there because the option was available. Then it seemed strange to have to login again to the forum. Appropriate messages would make it less confusing if two sign-ins are essential, and is presumably the easiest option (apart from just leaving it as it is and fielding the occasional query, of course Smile ).
Jamanda

You need to log in to the main site if you want to submit articles, which was really the whole point of the place in the first place.
marigold

You need to log in to the main site if you want to submit articles, which was really the whole point of the place in the first place.


Fair enough, but is that still relevant? As far as I can see there's nothing informing potential members that that is the case - simply a request to email the editor with ideas on the articles pages (why are there two BTW?) and the same instruction on the Author's Corner sticky.

I'm not criticising, just asking a question and making a suggestion.
Jamanda

The articles are the most important part of the site - without them there wouldn't be anything!

There are two pages atm because of the revamp. The ones that have been reformated are in one place and the ones that aren't finished yet are in the other.
marigold

The articles are the most important part of the site - without them there wouldn't be anything!


I understand that. However articles can be viewed without logging in and new articles are requested to be sent by email, so your explanation that login is required for submitting articles doesn't seem to be the correct. Which means that if it is technically easy, the home page login could be dispensed with, thus simplifying matters for general users. If Mods have to be logged in to submit articles that's a different issue and maybe it could be labeled "Mods login" or hidden from the hoi poloi.


There are two pages atm because of the revamp. The ones that have been reformated are in one place and the ones that aren't finished yet are in the other.

Thank - I understand that issue now.
sean

I think a re-label is probably the simplest solution. If we hide it I'll have to add yet another bookmark to my browser or I'll forget where it is. Smile marigold

I think a re-label is probably the simplest solution. If we hide it I'll have to add yet another bookmark to my browser or I'll forget where it is. Smile

Does that mean I'm right in assuming that the home page login is only relevant to Mods?
sean

I'm not sure. I think that if you've written an article you can go back in and edit it whether you're a mod or not. So maybe just calling it editorial log-in or something would be the way forwards. marigold

Fairy nuff. Thanks for taking my point on board. I'll leave it with the Mods and techies to decide what, if anything, should be done. Barefoot Andrew

Historically any DS member has been able to submit an article for consideration by logging into the main site. Same goes for suggesting a web link. These days however, potential articles are generally discussed in the forum and/or submitted via email. So in that regard, you're right - the login link is only useful to the publishing group - and indeed we took off the submit article/web links feature on the revamp.

A.
Jamanda

Historically any DS member has been able to submit an article for consideration by logging into the main site. Same goes for suggesting a web link. These days however, potential articles are generally discussed in the forum and/or submitted via email. So in that regard, you're right - the login link is only useful to the publishing group - and indeed we took off the submit article/web links feature on the revamp.

A.

Maybe it could say "publishing log-in". The impression that it's only for mods is the wrong message. how can we improve that?
Barefoot Andrew

The wording could be changed, or the link could be moved away from the main menu and placed on the copyright bar at the bottom.

A.
marigold



Maybe it could say "publishing log-in". The impression that it's only for mods is the wrong message. how can we improve that?

The wording could be changed, or the link could be moved away from the main menu and placed on the copyright bar at the bottom.

A.

Both suggestions make sense to me, could you do both?
Barefoot Andrew

I shall defer to the folk who use that link the most.
A.
Jamanda

I don't think people would see it down at the bottom. Barefoot Andrew

The people who use it would be the people who know where it is...
A.
Jamanda

The people who use it would be the people who know where it is...
A.

Hmm. If you only use it once in blue moon you might forget. I might forget and I use it as much as anyone other than you!
Barefoot Andrew

I'm afraid I'm going to resist changing the text to something longer like "publishing sign-in" or something along those lines - it renders the menu imbalanced IMHO.

There has always been a login link on the front page - although admittedly this wasn't in such a prime location as it is now. Perhaps we could adjust the text on the sign-in page to make its purpose clear, and distinguish it from the forum login.

A.
vegplot

Would 'publish' be too long or too cryptic? Nick

Is it really an issue? marigold


There has always been a login link on the front page - although admittedly this wasn't in such a prime location as it is now. Perhaps we could adjust the text on the sign-in page to make its purpose clear, and distinguish it from the forum login.

A.

That would work - could you put a link to the forum sign in on that page?

"This page is for editorial sign-in, to sign into the forum please got to this page"

Presumably it's not a big issue if no-one but me has commented on it, but I do think a small adjustment would help make things clearer.
       Downsizer Forum Index -> Site guidelines, Announcements, Problems and Suggestions
Page 1 of 1
Home Home Home Home Home